The Ciambra review - supremely effective storytelling

'This Is England' meets 'Gomorrah' in one boy’s passage into manhood

share this article

Pio (pictured left) and his family play fictional versions on themselves

The Ciambra is a wonderful and subtle piece of filmmaking. Director/writer Jonas Carpignano captures the genuine heart and fire of family relationships with an amateur cast of relatives, led by the magnetic young Pio Amato. By trusting the audience to find the subtext themselves, they create touching and persuasive cinema over two hours.

Pio is 14-years-old, living with his large family in the Romani community known as the Ciambra, in south Italy. Life here is tough – the electricity is stolen, and money is made by hijacking cars for ransom. Age works differently here, with establishing shots showing children drinking alcohol and toddlers smoking. Pio may be a teenager, but he feels ready to be a man.

His opportunity arises when the men of the house are arrested. The family’s left with a big bill, no income, and the mafia breathing down their neck, so Pio decides to start earning some cash. With the help of his older friend Ayiva, from the African immigrant community, Pio proves quite the entrepreneur, but soon finds adult life isn’t as simple and fun as it looks.

The Amato family in The Ciambra

Pio’s journey, although more illegal than most, is immediately familiar. That age when you want to be taken seriously and respected, even if your actions don't call for it. He reveres his older brother’s lifestyle of stealing and clubbing, but he’s driven by more than carnal lust and greed; he feels a sense of responsibility to both his immediate family and his traveller ancestry.

Without ever spelling it out, director Jonas Carpignano paints a vivid picture of adolescent confusion. The pride of making money, the fear of being caught red-handed, the heartbreak of disappointing your family. For much of the film, the camera is a passenger to Pio’s missions, only occasionally giving way to gorgeous dreamlike sequences that emphasise the weight of familial responsibility. There’s a confidence in Carpignano’s storytelling, with a lot of trust placed in the inexperienced cast.

It’s a work of fiction, but the lines are heavily blurred. Carpignano first met the Amato family after a crew car was stolen during filming of his debut Mediterranea. He became enthralled by the energy and lives of the Ciambra, and later cast Pio and his family as the stars of his next feature. Their performances are wonderfully understated, clearly untrained but grounded in truth. Pio tells a story in his eyes alone, determination and vulnerability carried in a look; there’s a career ahead of him, should he choose to leave the Ciambra life.

Set pieces and choice conversations build to an unexpected, bittersweet denouement. At times, it feels like the story is treading water, but foundations are laid for an ending that’s as poignant as it is modest. All the factions - the Romani gypsies, the African immigrants, the Mafiosi - believe they're above each other, but the film demonstrates we all share the same drives, the same loyalties, and the same inevitable loss of childhood.

@OwenRichards91

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
Pio tells a story in his eyes alone, determination and vulnerability carried in a look

rating

4

explore topics

share this article

the future of arts journalism

You can stop theartsdesk.com closing! 

We urgently need financing to survive. Our fundraising drive has thus far raised £33,000 but we need to reach £100,000 or we will be forced to close. Please contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d

And if you can forward this information to anyone who might assist, we’d be grateful.

more film

Russia's Tarantino's Hollywood debut is derivative but delirious
A lawyer sinks into a bureaucratic quagmire in a darkly humane Stalinist parable
Taut, engrossing low-budget thriller from an underrated director
The Italian star talks about his third portrayal of an Italian head of state
Sorrentino's latest political character study is cast in shades of grieving grey
Ryan Gosling fights to save Earth in a family sf epic of rare optimism
The little guy against the system: Bill Skarsgård and Dacre Montgomery star
'One Battle After Another' is the big winner over 'Sinners' amid a leaden Oscars that mixed impassioned politics with too much painful filler
A curious, cautious tale about sampling the Führer’s grub
Hlynur Pálmason creates an entrancing, novel form of film-as-memory
Director Rebecca Ziotowski gives Jodie Foster a free rein in French
Jessie Buckley and Christian Bale are a scream as lovestruck monsters on the run