Founder rate ends 9th September.

We’re rebuilding theartsdesk to secure the future of real arts journalism. Be part of it by subscribing: if you do it now, the founders’ rate of just £40 yearly is yours FOR LIFE!

SUBSCRIBE NOW 

Wang, RSNO, Oundjian, Usher Hall, Edinburgh review - percussion sets Shostakovich's 'Leningrad' ablaze

Music Director pairs two very different Russian works in his final season

share this article

Peter Oundjian: visceral Shostakovich
Sian Richards

Featuring two Russian composers, the two halves of the Royal Scottish National Orchestra’s programme could hardly have been more different. In the first, pianist Xiayin Wang (pictured below) joined the RSNO for Scriabin’s florid, rarely-heard Piano Concerto. The orchestral sound under Peter Oundjian – in what is his final season as Music Director – was lean yet strong, as the vast number of violins played as a single, powerful muscle.

While this made for a captivating orchestral presence, Wang’s solo playing was for most of the first movement either overshadowed or downright drowned out. Which was a shame, since when audible, it was rather lovely. She gave an illustrated level of detail to the score showing a mastery of the technicalities of the piece. During the unaccompanied passages of the second movement, she exuded a dream-like quality from the piano’s upper registers that gave gentle, celestial qualities to the music, but still had a sharp, zesty piquancy.

Wang’s playing in the third and final movement was, at long last, rousing and strong, but she still struggled to hold her own over the orchestra’s vast forces. While she rose to the fore for much of it, at times in the final sections the piano was yet again lost to an overly bulky blanket of strings. There’s no doubt that Wang is an exceptionally talented musician with an intensive mastery of her instrument, and her playing on Friday was detailed, animated and intelligent. It was sadly just a little too polite to fully carry the depth of Scriabin’s score, especially against such a large orchestra. Xiayin WangOundjian once again took to the podium for a far more lengthy second half. Shostakovich’s meaty Seventh Symphony, the "Leningrad", was given a thorough and visceral exposition. This is where such a huge string section makes sense. The uniformity of such a vast number of musicians boldly marked the angular lines of the symphony’s opening bars, and the orchestra was sensitive to the solo playing of those from among their own ranks – perhaps more so than to the first half’s soloist. A soft, single snare drum was beautifully complemented by steady pizzicatos, and as the tune was passed around the woodwind, the instrumental balance was always spot on, with a precise dynamic variance unfortunately missing in the concert’s first half. Even when the music turned to its most tumultuous and cacophonous, Oundjian seamlessly maintained the music’s stability.

Shifting to the dignified second movement, principal oboist Adrian Wilson’s solo was gorgeously light and lyrical. There are dark undertones to this movement, but these were understated, and even the piercing E flat clarinet solo had an elegance to match its edge

Oundjian steered the orchestra powerfully through the stark differences in musical mindsets, from the serene to spiky rhythms of the third movement to the myriad moods of the tempestuous finale. By its second part, the music’s hard edge had softened a little bit, but there was still a steeliness to it: a resolve, a determination, a primary-coloured vibrancy. This is a symphony jam packed with ideas, and the RSNO on Friday night gave voice to each and every one with strings both silky yet strong, clear and precise woodwind and rich brass. It was the percussion’s night, though; the bite of the snare drum and build of the timpani exuded a gripping potential energy that seeped into the pores of the piece, further igniting Shostakovich's triumphant score.

Oundjian steered the orchestra powerfully through the stark differences in musical mindsets

rating

4

share this article

Help secure the future of arts journalism

In this era of algorithmic recommendation, opaquely sponsored content and AI slop, theartsdesk’s mission to preserve real journalistic and critical values has never been more important.

If you like what you see here, please join us 
in this mission.

Subscribing to the site will help us in our coming 
redesign and expansion.


If you do this before the 9th September this will be at our guaranteed founder’s rate: 
your subs will never increase again.

Subscribe now for £5 per month. 
or yearly for just £40.

Or if you simply want to support us with a one-off donation, you can do so here.

more classical music

Natural scenes with birdsong fill a varied programme
The bigger the chorus, the harder to catch the words of great poetry
The Estonian Festival Orchestra rules supreme, but other aspects just got even better
A rapid Beethoven 9 and a showcase for the phenomenal Abel Selaocoe
Finnish music from Finnish conductors, life-enhancing minimalism and massed gongs
Eloquent thoughts on the wonder of 'Dichterliebe' and a new work inspired by it
Latest in a line of great Irish mezzos shows her versatility, and the strings swoon
A pair of much-loved cello concertos, plus percussion transcriptions and a great German song cycle
Two recitals in a thousand, other events good to excellent
Distinction and emotional impact from young musicians and an exuberant maestro