DVD: Mario Lanza - The Best of Everything

Born Alfred Arnold Cocozza to immigrant working-class Italian parents in Philadelphia, Mario Lanza was lauded by the likes of Serge Koussevitsky and Arturo Toscanini, becoming a huge Hollywood star by the early 1950s.

The cracks were already beginning to show, though: Lanza’s huge appetites and ballooning weight were beginning to be a concern, and director Curtis Bernhardt laughably disapproved of the “excess passion” which Lanza displayed when recording the arias for his next film, The Student Prince. He was fired, his fulsome vocals subsequently mimed to by another actor. Lanza’s career never quite regained momentum. The weight continued to see-saw, a tendency controlled by crash diets, and Lanza developed gout, high blood pressure and phlebitis. He suffered at the hands of incompetent management, and the supremely confident stage manner was revealed to be a front; Lanza would often cancel performances at the very last minute, eventually relocating with his family to Rome in an attempt to rebuild his career.

He starred in a few more mediocre films (1959's For the First Time, with Zsa Zsa Gabor, pictured right), but the damage was done. Lanza suffered a fatal heart attack in 1959, aged just 38, his wife dying just months later. Alan Byron’s no-frills documentary, narrated in soporific fashion by Radio 2's Ken Bruce, argues convincingly that Lanza was the first crossover superstar. At its best when showing Lanza in action, it’s clear that he did possess an alluring, highly expressive voice. Though it’s frustrating that none of the talking heads assembled (a motley bunch including Genesis’s Steve Hackett, soprano Lesley Garrett and crossover tenor Russell Watson) would have actually heard Lanza live. We’re also left in the dark about how much of what we hear was down to the work of studio engineers, though an avuncular voice coach has a decent stab at analysing the singer's vocal technique. The most engaging interviewee is Lanza’s surviving daughter Ellisa. This story deserves a big budget biopic. Until it gets made, this serviceable film will have to do. As a bonus, there's footage of Lanza's 1957 appearance at the London Palladium.

• More film reviews on theartsdesk