Arthur Smith, Brighton Fringe review - touching memoir of his dad | reviews, news & interviews
Arthur Smith, Brighton Fringe review - touching memoir of his dad
Arthur Smith, Brighton Fringe review - touching memoir of his dad
Strong start to the festival

“A real live audience,” said Arthur Smith delightedly as he kicked off the Brighton Fringe with Syd, his touching and funny tribute to his late father, “an ordinary man who lived in extraordinary times” – his life included a stint in Dad's Army (the Home Guard) and as a prisoner of war in Colditz Castle, and for decades he was a bobby on the beat in south London.
Smith was glad to be in The Warren, as were the audience, in a pop-up space that he described as “a yellow metal Globe”, made from brightly painted shipping containers and metal railings, with the occasional, fitting, accompaniment of sirens from passing police cars. Smith has been performing this show on and off since 2018 (with a lengthy lay-off last year, of course) and it was good to revisit it, as he has added several sharp gags at the expense of Brexit voters (rare in these parts) and Old Etonians, particularly those in government.
The main thrust of the show remains with Smith reading from the memoirs he fortuitously asked his father to write in his last years (he died in 2004), while filling in his own life history with anecdotes, songs and stories – and some cracking dad jokes. Syd's memoirs relate that much of his time as a constable was taken up with dealing with drunks, but trying not to arrest them if doing so would mean missing a football match to appear in court.
The strongest part of the show is where Smith cleverly contrasts his father’s youth – spent in uniform as he went from teenage soldier with Dad’s Army to regular soldier, being captured at El Alamein – with his own, as a callow student in Paris learning first-hand the meaning of ménage à trois and failing to be the political firebrand he fancied himself as when he lost his glasses during a demonstration.
Smith senior was clearly not a man for making grand statements. When his son took him to stay at Colditz Castle some decades after he was an unwilling guest during the war, his reaction on seeing it again was “There it is”. Syd had to survive on rats during the war, and the answer to his son's obvious question was: “Oh you know, tastes like dog.”
Great support is given by pianist and singer Kirsty Newton. It was lovely to see the Brighton Fringe off to a strong start.
rating
Explore topics
Share this article
The future of Arts Journalism
You can stop theartsdesk.com closing!
We urgently need financing to survive. Our fundraising drive has thus far raised £49,000 but we need to reach £100,000 or we will be forced to close. Please contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d
And if you can forward this information to anyone who might assist, we’d be grateful.

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take a subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more Comedy
 'We are bowled over!' Thank you for your messages of love and support 
  
  
    
      Much-appreciated words of commendation from readers and the cultural community
  
  
    
      'We are bowled over!' Thank you for your messages of love and support 
  
  
    
      Much-appreciated words of commendation from readers and the cultural community
  
     Emma Doran, Leicester Square Theatre review - domestic life laid bare
  
  
    
      Irish comic mixes sentiment and sauciness
  
  
    
      Emma Doran, Leicester Square Theatre review - domestic life laid bare
  
  
    
      Irish comic mixes sentiment and sauciness
  
     Janine Harouni, Soho Theatre review - families and surviving them
  
  
    
      US comic's slick show about relationships
  
  
    
      Janine Harouni, Soho Theatre review - families and surviving them
  
  
    
      US comic's slick show about relationships
  
     Bryony Kimmings, Soho Theatre Walthamstow review - captivating tale of the cycle of life
  
  
    
      Witty ode to Mother Nature
  
  
    
      Bryony Kimmings, Soho Theatre Walthamstow review - captivating tale of the cycle of life
  
  
    
      Witty ode to Mother Nature
  
     The Free Association launch review - strong start for improv company
  
  
    
      Troupe moves into permanent home
  
  
    
      The Free Association launch review - strong start for improv company
  
  
    
      Troupe moves into permanent home
  
     Nick Helm, Touring review - brash comic shows his vulnerable side
  
  
    
       Matters of the heart and heavy metal
  
  
    
      Nick Helm, Touring review - brash comic shows his vulnerable side
  
  
    
       Matters of the heart and heavy metal
  
     Kerry Godliman, G-Live review - she's livid but delivers the laughs
  
  
    
      Perimenopause provides rich seam of gags
  
  
    
      Kerry Godliman, G-Live review - she's livid but delivers the laughs
  
  
    
      Perimenopause provides rich seam of gags
  
     Edinburgh Fringe 2025 reviews - Cat Cohen / Lachlan Werner / KC Shornima
  
  
    
      Defying a health scare; a surreal invention & a distinctive new voice
  
  
    
      Edinburgh Fringe 2025 reviews - Cat Cohen / Lachlan Werner / KC Shornima
  
  
    
      Defying a health scare; a surreal invention & a distinctive new voice
  
     Edinburgh Fringe 2025 reviews - Emmanuel Sonubi / Joz Norris
  
  
    
      A second chance at life & a fantastical tale about artistic endeavour
  
  
    
      Edinburgh Fringe 2025 reviews - Emmanuel Sonubi / Joz Norris
  
  
    
      A second chance at life & a fantastical tale about artistic endeavour
  
     Edinburgh Fringe 2025 reviews - Eric Rushton / Bella Hull
  
  
    
      Depression laid bare & a relationship decoded
  
  
    
      Edinburgh Fringe 2025 reviews - Eric Rushton / Bella Hull
  
  
    
      Depression laid bare & a relationship decoded
  
     Edinburgh Fringe 2025 reviews - Lily Blumkin / Shamik Chakrabarti
  
  
    
      A life in several characters & a Mumbai shaggy-dog story
  
  
    
      Edinburgh Fringe 2025 reviews - Lily Blumkin / Shamik Chakrabarti
  
  
    
      A life in several characters & a Mumbai shaggy-dog story
  
     Edinburgh Fringe 2025 reviews - Desiree Burch / Andy Parsons
  
  
    
      The delights of perimenopause & pertinent political comedy
  
  
    
      Edinburgh Fringe 2025 reviews - Desiree Burch / Andy Parsons
  
  
    
      The delights of perimenopause & pertinent political comedy 
  
    
Add comment