The Culture Show: Girls Will Be Girls, BBC Two | reviews, news & interviews
The Culture Show: Girls Will Be Girls, BBC Two
The Culture Show: Girls Will Be Girls, BBC Two
Exploration of women in punk strikes only a few bum notes
In 40 years’ time, when some suit at the BBC is searching the archives for some suitable footage to illustrate women in music in the early 21st century, will he pull out an image of Miley Cyrus or Rihanna wrapped in fishnets and bondage tape?
I may seem disenchanted, but it was one of only a few unintentional sour notes struck by Girls Will Be Girls - most of the rest were part of the soundtrack and were as glorious as presenter Miranda Sawyer’s interviews with the likes of Viv Albertine, Chrissie Hynde (pictured, below right) and The Raincoats’ Ana da Silva and Gina Birch. And even if the documentary paid mere lip service to the roles played by women in contemporary underground music, the fact that all four continue to break new ground through solo careers that embrace and revel in the life experiences and perspectives of older women is something to be celebrated.
It was one of only a few unintentional sour notes
Former Slits guitarist Albertine brought out a memoir (the brilliantly titled Clothes, Clothes, Clothes. Music, Music, Music. Boys, Boys, Boys) a few weeks ago, and her debut solo album The Vermillion Border is not much older. So it stood to reason that she commanded the bulk of the interview time, speaking passionately about her time in The Slits and a little about what came after. It took time - and the input of Chrissie Hynde - for Albertine to see her place in an almost always all-female band as the radical act it later appeared: instead, Johnny Rotten and the rest of the Sex Pistols were her early inspirations. Rotten was, she said, “as near a girl like me as a boy could be” - an epiphany that led to her buying a guitar that she couldn’t play with £200 she was left by her grandmother, forming a short-lived band with Sid Vicious and ultimately joining The Slits shortly after their first show in March 1977.
Albertine’s affection for The Slits frontwoman Ari Up, who died of cancer in 2010, provides some of the documentary’s most touching moments: her famous pissing on stage was not, the guitarist said, intended as some controversial act but rather the direct result of the unusually liberated and confident singer just needing to go. Interviews with the members of The Raincoats were disappointingly short, but provided tantalising glimpses of what the confidence of The Slits meant for other female musicians.
And the role of women in the punk movement wasn’t just limited to musicians, as Sawyer illustrated through interviews with photographer Sheila Rock and the still-fabulous style icon Jordan, whose clothing on her way to work at Vivienne Westwood and Malcolm McLaren’s infamous SEX boutique was so provocative she used to be upgraded to first class train travel for her own protection. The delightful Rock, whose style was inspired by the punk musicians that she shot - essentially, she photographed what she thought was interesting and learned as she went along - provided another of the documentary’s inadvertently hilarious moments as Sawyer flicked through an album featuring photographs of Siouxie Sioux. “She’s wearing a t-shirt that shows two…” “Tits,” the older woman interrupted, before Sawyer could hide behind some 21st century euphemism.
The future of Arts Journalism
You can stop theartsdesk.com closing!
We urgently need financing to survive. Our fundraising drive has thus far raised £49,000 but we need to reach £100,000 or we will be forced to close. Please contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d
And if you can forward this information to anyone who might assist, we’d be grateful.

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take a subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more TV
 theartsdesk Q&A: director Stefano Sollima on the relevance of true crime story 'The Monster of Florence'
  
  
    
      The director of hit TV series 'Gomorrah' examines another dark dimension of Italian culture
  
  
    
      theartsdesk Q&A: director Stefano Sollima on the relevance of true crime story 'The Monster of Florence'
  
  
    
      The director of hit TV series 'Gomorrah' examines another dark dimension of Italian culture
  
     The Monster of Florence, Netflix review - dramatisation of notorious Italian serial killer mystery
  
  
    
      Director Stefano Sollima's four-parter makes gruelling viewing
  
  
    
      The Monster of Florence, Netflix review - dramatisation of notorious Italian serial killer mystery
  
  
    
      Director Stefano Sollima's four-parter makes gruelling viewing
  
     The Diplomat, Season 3, Netflix review - Ambassador Kate Wyler becomes America's Second Lady
  
  
    
      Soapy transatlantic political drama keeps the Special Relationship alive
  
  
    
      The Diplomat, Season 3, Netflix review - Ambassador Kate Wyler becomes America's Second Lady
  
  
    
      Soapy transatlantic political drama keeps the Special Relationship alive
  
     The Perfect Neighbor, Netflix review - Florida found-footage documentary is a harrowing watch
  
  
    
      Sundance winner chronicles a death that should have been prevented
  
  
    
      The Perfect Neighbor, Netflix review - Florida found-footage documentary is a harrowing watch
  
  
    
      Sundance winner chronicles a death that should have been prevented
  
     Murder Before Evensong, Acorn TV review - death comes to the picturesque village of Champton
  
  
    
      The Rev Richard Coles's sleuthing cleric hits the screen
  
  
    
      Murder Before Evensong, Acorn TV review - death comes to the picturesque village of Champton
  
  
    
      The Rev Richard Coles's sleuthing cleric hits the screen
  
     Black Rabbit, Netflix review - grime and punishment in New York City
  
  
    
      Jude Law and Jason Bateman tread the thin line between love and hate
  
  
    
      Black Rabbit, Netflix review - grime and punishment in New York City
  
  
    
      Jude Law and Jason Bateman tread the thin line between love and hate
  
     The Hack, ITV review - plodding anatomy of twin UK scandals
  
  
    
      Jack Thorne's skill can't disguise the bagginess of his double-headed material
  
  
    
      The Hack, ITV review - plodding anatomy of twin UK scandals
  
  
    
      Jack Thorne's skill can't disguise the bagginess of his double-headed material
  
     Slow Horses, Series 5, Apple TV+ review - terror, trauma and impeccable comic timing
  
  
    
      Jackson Lamb's band of MI5 misfits continues to fascinate and amuse
  
  
    
      Slow Horses, Series 5, Apple TV+ review - terror, trauma and impeccable comic timing
  
  
    
      Jackson Lamb's band of MI5 misfits continues to fascinate and amuse
  
     Coldwater, ITV1 review - horror and black comedy in the Highlands
  
  
    
      Superb cast lights up David Ireland's cunning thriller
  
  
    
      Coldwater, ITV1 review - horror and black comedy in the Highlands
  
  
    
      Superb cast lights up David Ireland's cunning thriller
  
     Blu-ray: The Sweeney - Series One
  
  
    
      Influential and entertaining 1970s police drama, handsomely restored
  
  
    
      Blu-ray: The Sweeney - Series One
  
  
    
      Influential and entertaining 1970s police drama, handsomely restored
  
     I Fought the Law, ITVX review - how an 800-year-old law was challenged and changed
  
  
    
      Sheridan Smith's raw performance dominates ITV's new docudrama about injustice
  
  
    
      I Fought the Law, ITVX review - how an 800-year-old law was challenged and changed
  
  
    
      Sheridan Smith's raw performance dominates ITV's new docudrama about injustice 
  
     The Paper, Sky Max review - a spinoff of the US Office worth waiting 20 years for
  
  
    
      Perfectly judged recycling of the original's key elements, with a star turn at its heart
  
  
    
      The Paper, Sky Max review - a spinoff of the US Office worth waiting 20 years for
  
  
    
      Perfectly judged recycling of the original's key elements, with a star turn at its heart
  
    
Add comment