Film: Up | reviews, news & interviews
Film: Up
Film: Up
Uplifting experience or simply hot air?
Wednesday, 07 October 2009
Animators often give their heroes superlative physical powers just because they can. Mr Fredricksen, the grumpy septuagenarian at the centre of Up, has by contrast a hearing aid, false teeth, a walker and a stairlift that's on the blink. It's a struggle for him to heave himself out of his armchair. He could betoken a bold break with movie stereotypes or simply be a sign that Hollywood, so long obsessed with the youth demographic, is finally wising up to the power of the grey dollar.
Up arrives in Britain on the wings of ecstatic reviews from American critics. It is an immaculately polished package, from the short film, Partly Cloudy (right), that precedes it and sets the skyward theme, to the delightful doodles that embellish the end credits. Over the last two decades the Pixar powerhouse has produced nothing but hits, from Toy Story and The Incredibles to Ratatouille and WALL-E. Up, too, will fly high in the box-office charts even though, dramatically speaking, it's broken-backed.
The start of it is stonking. A tremendously sweet and graceful opening montage condenses Mr F's entre life story into a couple of near-wordless minutes. We get to know the person behind the old-man mask of grey hair, wrinkles and big black specs. His childhood worship of a dashing explorer named Charles Muntz, whose exploits he follows in cinema newsreels, yearning to follow in his footsteps to a remote, magical valley in Venezuela. The gap-toothed little tomboy who shares his passion and blossoms into the love of his life. Their dreams and bitter disappointments and quiet, lasting contentment.
And then the trauma of bereavement, the indignities of lonely old age and the solitary confinement in the home which he has turned into a mausoleum. One day two politely uncaring nurses come to cart Mr F off to die in a gated retirement community. His response is a magnificent, spontaneous act of rebellion, uplifting in every sense.
In fact, Mr F is not without precedent. Howl's Moving Castle (left), by the great Japanese animator Hayao Miyazaki, had a young woman spending most of the story transformed into an ancient crone, and eventually embracing the experience. All of Miyazaki's work is also suffused with a passion for flying, and he has been a potent influence on the Pixar team.
Still, these are things rarely seen in mainstream family features, animated or otherwise. But then, like WALL-E before it (which was written by Pete Docter, the co-director of Up), the film loses its nerve. It slips, as perhaps it must, into something more ordinary, something designed to say, "Hey, kids, this is for you too." Still very good, make no mistake about it. But a standard action adventure nonetheless, of recognisable lineage, son of Lara Croft and grandson of Indiana Jones.
Mr F has, much to his dismay, acquired a comic sidekick, a very fat, chocolate and hot-dog munching boy scout named Russell. A junior Pangloss, the ever-enthusiastic Russell also aches to be outward bound, no matter that his main navigational skills depend on his mobile phone's GPS system. And off they waft together through the ether towards an uncharted continent ("South America! It's like America! Only South!"), where they run into magical creatures and Mr F's boyhood hero, who turns out not to be heroic at all.
There's a rare multi-coloured bird named Kevin which looks rather like a big, tropical cousin of the Road Runner, and a pack of talking hounds (in a cute narrative trick to explain why they can speak, they wear special dog-to-human translator-collars, invented by Muntz - amusingly, the scary alpha Doberman has a broken collar that distorts his voice into a silly high-pitched squawk).
There's some phantasmagorial set design, worthy of a James Bond movie, on display in the villain's lair, a cavernous airship; Muntz himself is a satisfyingly complex creation, a brilliant man driven to madness by his obsession. There is a lot of shouting and chases; and Mr F's walker comes in mighty handy on numerous occasions in assisting their escape from tight spots.
The trouble is (and this might seem like an odd observation to make of digitally animated characters) Mr Fredricksen and Russell lack screen chemistry. Their relationship is driven by cliche: they are just another brace of mismatched buddies and, if you were to predict that a close friendship would eventually form between the boy abandoned by his father and the curmudgeonly old man who was unable to have children, you would not be too wide of the mark. The bond between Mr F and his wife - though she is absent for most of the movie - is much more compelling.
But those canny Pixar people wouldn't want you to come out of Up feeling down. So the film rallies triumphantly in its closing stretches. (It is egregiously sentimental, but Pixar's achievement is to convey emotional truths with the lightest touch). Mr F spends much of the movie dragging his house behind him through the jungle - an extraordinarily resonant image, this, with shades of Werner Herzog's Fitzcarraldo. Finally, he learns to let go of his past, in the most literal sense, and feels entitled to carve out for himself a new kind of modest happiness. Though billed as a thrill-packed adventure, Up concludes that it's the smallest, most ordinary moments in life that contain the greatest adventures of all.
Up opens across Britain tomorrow.
The start of it is stonking. A tremendously sweet and graceful opening montage condenses Mr F's entre life story into a couple of near-wordless minutes. We get to know the person behind the old-man mask of grey hair, wrinkles and big black specs. His childhood worship of a dashing explorer named Charles Muntz, whose exploits he follows in cinema newsreels, yearning to follow in his footsteps to a remote, magical valley in Venezuela. The gap-toothed little tomboy who shares his passion and blossoms into the love of his life. Their dreams and bitter disappointments and quiet, lasting contentment.
And then the trauma of bereavement, the indignities of lonely old age and the solitary confinement in the home which he has turned into a mausoleum. One day two politely uncaring nurses come to cart Mr F off to die in a gated retirement community. His response is a magnificent, spontaneous act of rebellion, uplifting in every sense.
In fact, Mr F is not without precedent. Howl's Moving Castle (left), by the great Japanese animator Hayao Miyazaki, had a young woman spending most of the story transformed into an ancient crone, and eventually embracing the experience. All of Miyazaki's work is also suffused with a passion for flying, and he has been a potent influence on the Pixar team.
Still, these are things rarely seen in mainstream family features, animated or otherwise. But then, like WALL-E before it (which was written by Pete Docter, the co-director of Up), the film loses its nerve. It slips, as perhaps it must, into something more ordinary, something designed to say, "Hey, kids, this is for you too." Still very good, make no mistake about it. But a standard action adventure nonetheless, of recognisable lineage, son of Lara Croft and grandson of Indiana Jones.
Mr F has, much to his dismay, acquired a comic sidekick, a very fat, chocolate and hot-dog munching boy scout named Russell. A junior Pangloss, the ever-enthusiastic Russell also aches to be outward bound, no matter that his main navigational skills depend on his mobile phone's GPS system. And off they waft together through the ether towards an uncharted continent ("South America! It's like America! Only South!"), where they run into magical creatures and Mr F's boyhood hero, who turns out not to be heroic at all.
There's a rare multi-coloured bird named Kevin which looks rather like a big, tropical cousin of the Road Runner, and a pack of talking hounds (in a cute narrative trick to explain why they can speak, they wear special dog-to-human translator-collars, invented by Muntz - amusingly, the scary alpha Doberman has a broken collar that distorts his voice into a silly high-pitched squawk).
There's some phantasmagorial set design, worthy of a James Bond movie, on display in the villain's lair, a cavernous airship; Muntz himself is a satisfyingly complex creation, a brilliant man driven to madness by his obsession. There is a lot of shouting and chases; and Mr F's walker comes in mighty handy on numerous occasions in assisting their escape from tight spots.
The trouble is (and this might seem like an odd observation to make of digitally animated characters) Mr Fredricksen and Russell lack screen chemistry. Their relationship is driven by cliche: they are just another brace of mismatched buddies and, if you were to predict that a close friendship would eventually form between the boy abandoned by his father and the curmudgeonly old man who was unable to have children, you would not be too wide of the mark. The bond between Mr F and his wife - though she is absent for most of the movie - is much more compelling.
But those canny Pixar people wouldn't want you to come out of Up feeling down. So the film rallies triumphantly in its closing stretches. (It is egregiously sentimental, but Pixar's achievement is to convey emotional truths with the lightest touch). Mr F spends much of the movie dragging his house behind him through the jungle - an extraordinarily resonant image, this, with shades of Werner Herzog's Fitzcarraldo. Finally, he learns to let go of his past, in the most literal sense, and feels entitled to carve out for himself a new kind of modest happiness. Though billed as a thrill-packed adventure, Up concludes that it's the smallest, most ordinary moments in life that contain the greatest adventures of all.
Up opens across Britain tomorrow.
more
Interview: Marco Bellocchio – the last maestro
Italian cinema's vigorous grand old man discusses Kidnapped, conversion, anarchy and faith in cinema
Testmatch, Orange Tree Theatre review - Raj rage, old and new, flares in cricket dramedy
Winning performances cannot overcome a scattergun approach to a ragbag of issues
Album: Justice - Hyperdrama
French electronic dance stalwarts return from eight-year break in fine fettle
Classical CDs: Swans, hamlets and bossa nova
A promising young pianist's debut disc, plus Finnish mythology and a trio of neglected British composers
I.S.S. review - sci-fi with a sting in the tail
The imperilled space station isn't the worst place to be
Album: St Vincent - All Born Screaming
Annie Clark transcends indie’s average leanings
Eye to Eye: Homage to Ernst Scheidegger, MASI Lugano review - era-defining artist portraits
One of Switzerland's greatest photographers celebrated with a major retrospective
Christian Pierre La Marca, Yaman Okur, St Martin-in-The-Fields review - engagingly subversive pairing falls short
A collaboration between a cellist and a breakdancer doesn't achieve lift off
That They May Face The Rising Sun review - lyrical adaptation of John McGahern's novel
Pat Collins extracts the magic of country life in the west of Ireland in his third feature film
Album: Pet Shop Boys - Nonetheless
Longing, love and longevity as the duo resolutely refuse retirement
Ridout, Włoszczowska, Crawford, Lai, Posner, Wigmore Hall review - electrifying teamwork
High-voltage Mozart and Schoenberg, blended Brahms, in a fascinating programme
Stephen review - a breathtakingly good first feature by a multi-media artist
Melanie Manchot's debut is strikingly intelligent and compelling
Add comment