Turner Prize is won for the third time in a row by a Scottish artist

George Shaw might have been the popular favourite, but it was Martin Boyce who carried the vote to win this year’s Turner Prize. The 44-year-old artist from Hamilton, South Lanarkshire, follows fast on the heels of two fellow Scots: Susan Philipsz won the prize in 2010 and Richard Wright in 2009. But neither seemed as much of a clear-cut choice as Boyce, for although the public vote wasn’t his, the critics were pretty much united in backing him.

Boyce’s installation (main picture), which takes as its starting reference a series of sculptures by French Modernists Joel and Jan Martel, is undeniably clever, elliptical and layered. In its meeting of utopian Modernism, defunct municipal architecture and natural landscape it is also deeply melancholic. The work is cerebral, whilst also being emotionally engaging – it carries with it a faint air of nostalgia that conveys something of the suburban whiff of a Seventies childhood. In this sense, his work can be compared to Shaw’s, who paints the Coventry estate in which he grew up (Shaw is 45, Boyce 44).  

But after I left the exhibition’s October press opening, it was really only Boyce’s work that kept playing on my mind, bringing new associations and fresh angles in its wake. Next to Hilary Lloyd and fellow Scot Karla Black, Boyce’s work simply has more traction.  

It was the first time the prize was held outside a Tate gallery. The curators at the Baltic Centre in Gateshead, which overlooks the spectacular River Tyne, did a superb job in installing all four artists: the Turner Prize exhibition has never appeared as attractive as in the Baltic’s small galleries. Meanwhile, Boyce was handed his winning £25,000 cheque by Mario Testino, a fashion photographer whose own work couldn’t be more different to the quietly contemplative work of each of the four nominees.

• Turner Prize 2011 at the Baltic, Gateshead until 8 January, 2012