Philippe Jaroussky, Concerto Cologne, Barbican

Philippe Jaroussky, Concerto Cologne, Barbican | reviews, news & interviews

Philippe Jaroussky, Concerto Cologne, Barbican

French countertenor hits heights but J C Bach fails to impress

by Igor ToronyilalicThursday, 03 December 2009

Nesting gay men and posh female totty by the bucketload in the audience last night. Fill any programme with Baroque opera and that’s what you get. Why? Because the Baroque is aspirational pop. It's grounded in the same musical tricks that drive on the chart-topping hits of Kylie or Madonna: pumping ostinati, unshake-offable tunes and harmonic Häagen-Dazs - obvious harmonic loops that you can't get enough of. Though last night the hook was even simpler: a beddable boy.

Looks weren’t the only or principal draw. French countertenor Philippe Jaroussky is joli-laid: lanky, boyish and chinny. But what a voice. Via a visual cacophony of bony, jerky body movements, the movements of a chick about to hatch, Jaroussky propels a sweet, euphonious, versatile sound that, whether in first gear, sotto voce or spitting out notes up by the ozone layer at the speed of sound, never fails to be anything but exquisite.

Having stuffed the programme with arias from the obscure operas of Johann Christian Bach (the 18th child of J S Bach), Jaroussky’s musical taste was on trial as much as his vocal talents. Could he resurrect the fortunes of this long-forgotten Bach, who once ruled the roost in musical London 300 years ago? The answer was a resounding no. We weren’t mean. We clapped politely, gave him his due, but the love wasn’t there.

JC is interesting only musicologically - not only for his prominence in shaping musical life in London in the mid to late 18th century but also for his contribution to the burgeoning Classical age. In terms of phrasing, orchestral layering and harmonic matters he obviously provided the young Mozart with some models to work with.

But his music singularly fails to excite. In the aria "Cara, la dolce fiamma" from his 1765 opera Adriano in Siria, never has a composer traversed so much ground to so little effect. It was as eventful as a featureless Arctic hike. Both "Ch’io parta?... Ma pensa" from Temistocle (1772) and "No, che non ha la sorte… Vo solcando un mar crudele" from Artaserse (1760) were interesting only for their musical proximity to a Mozartian sound world.

It was left to Handel to rescue the concert and Jaroussky. The countertenor looked more comfortable singing the great hits of Alcina, Ariodante, Tolomeo and Rinaldo than those of J C Bach. When you've got a technique like Jaroussky's you have to work far less to make the Handelian show-stoppers work - he seems most at ease at TGV speeds, rattling off the firecracker leaps and runs.

Having said this, he should calm down when calm is required; he has a tendency to overwork the pensive arias and to over-emote the emotional ones. And I hope the JC fad fades. Concerto Cologne, conducted from the harpsichord by Nicolau de Figueiredo (who also gave a performance of a completely mad JC harpsichord concerto as an interlude between arias), provided superb backing: windy, shapely and richly colourful.

The Great Performers series at the Barbican continues next week with a performance of the Messiah with Harry Bicket and The English Concert

Explore topics

Share this article

...

Permalink Submitted by N N Hilary (not verified) on Thu, 03/12/2009 - 23:30

Since when did "gay men", "posh female totty" and Philippe Jaroussky's looks have anything to do with the artistic success of a concert? Since when did the fact that an artist moves with music have any relevence? (Let's write off the whole continent of Africa). Jaroussky should console himself with the fact that Heifetz was criticised for standing still - yes, I did mention them both in the same sentence. "Just close your eyes and listen" said Perlman; this reviewer should do likewise. Most of this review, pandering as it does to the writer's obvious preferences - musical and otherwise - reads as if it were written before the event. Curiously, it fails to mention Jaroussky's curtain call AT THE INTERVAL, his three encores and his remarkable generosity of spirit in signing CDs for over an hour afterwards, and the fact that those of us at the end of the queue were prepared to wait that long for the great man's generous smile and tired scribble. Curiously, it fails to mention that if any aspect of this concert were worthy of criticism it would have to be the occasionally wayward intonation of the horns and flutes, against which Jaroussky's own pitch held perfect all evening ("superb backing"??!?). The music of J C Bach may have been little known to most of us there, and for me, it was also a first chance to see Jaroussky in concert. But by golly, naff horns or not, he sold us the whole package in the most blisteringly virtuosic and emotional performance. And by the way, I enjoy Handel and Mozart too.

...

Permalink Submitted by M. Dworkin (not verified) on Wed, 16/12/2009 - 22:43

I have never read anything so moronic masquerading as a concert review. Tronyi-Lalic should be ashamed of himself.

Add comment

The future of Arts Journalism

You can stop theartsdesk.com closing!

We urgently need financing to survive. Our fundraising drive has thus far raised £33,000 but we need to reach £100,000 or we will be forced to close. Please contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d

And if you can forward this information to anyone who might assist, we’d be grateful.

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?

more Classical music

Sheku Kanneh-Mason, Isata Kanneh-Mason, Wigmore Hall review - family fun, fire and finesse Intimacy and empathy in a varied mixture from the star siblings

Mahler 8, LPO, Gardner, RFH review - lights on high Perfect pacing allows climaxes to make their mark – and the visuals aren’t bad, either

Philharmonia, Alsop, RFH / Levit, Abramović, QEH review - misalliance and magical marathon Kentridge’s film for Shostakovich 10 goes its own way, but a master compels in his 13th hour of Satie

Bach St John Passion, Academy of Ancient Music, Cummings, Barbican review - conscience against conformism In an age of hate-fuelled pile-ons, Bach's gospel tragedy strikes even deeper

MacMillan St John Passion, Boylan, National Symphony Orchestra & Chorus, Hill, NCH Dublin review - flares around a fine Christ Young Irish baritone pulls focus in blazing performance of a 21st century classic

First Person: St John's College choral conductor Christopher Gray on recording 'Lament & Liberation' A showcase for contemporary choral works appropriate to this time

Classical CDs: Romance, reforestation and a Rolleiflex New music for choir, orchestra and string quartet, plus a tribute to a rediscovered photographer

Donohoe, RPO, Brabbins, Cadogan Hall review - rarely heard British piano concerto Welcome chance to hear a Bliss rarity alongside better-known British classics