'You can start a conversation': what's the point of critics? | reviews, news & interviews
'You can start a conversation': what's the point of critics?
'You can start a conversation': what's the point of critics?
Sunday, 04 April 2010
Everyone who likes his reviews on Radio FiveLive would have wanted Mark Kermode, the gobby critic who is well known for having seen just about everything. But he claims that he didn't want the job. And who knows if he'd have got it? Jonathan Ross's replacement as BBC One's resident film critic is Claudia Winkleman.
The announcement has been greeted with whoops of joy almost nowhere. Or nowhere in the critical fraternity (or whatever the collective noun is). But hell, at least there's still a television programme on a mainstream channel that thinks exclusively about film. At the Movies, American TV's film review show which once starred duelling critics Roger Ebert and Gene Siskel, has been given the thumbs down. It is to close at the end of its current run. This event has prompted AO Scott, one of its current presenters, to muse on the future of criticism in the New York Times, who are his other employers.
"You can start a conversation": that, he argues, is finally the critic's job. Just not his job any more, or not on television. And not many others' job either. At theartsdesk, we naturally ponder these matters more than most. Feel free to ponder them with us in the comment box.
"You can start a conversation": that, he argues, is finally the critic's job. Just not his job any more, or not on television. And not many others' job either. At theartsdesk, we naturally ponder these matters more than most. Feel free to ponder them with us in the comment box.
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take a subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more
Carmen, Glyndebourne review - total musical fusion
Production tells the story, mostly, but it’s the lead and the conductor who electrify
Fawlty Towers: The Play, Apollo Theatre review - lightning strikes twice
John Cleese's sitcom masterpiece makes seamless transition to the stage
Laufey, Royal Albert Hall review - fans in heaven
The sequence of heartbreak songs sounded same-y
The Great Escape Festival 2024, Brighton review - a dip into day one and the elephant-in-the-room
An opening snapshot of Brighton's multi-venue showcase
Bermondsey Tales: Fall of the Roman Empire review - dirty deeds done dirt cheap
Michael Head's gangland drama is a bit of a dog's breakfast
Album: Billie Eilish - Hit Me Hard and Soft
Desire and longing are the submersibles that propel Eilish’s riveting third album
Dunedin Consort, Mulroy, Wigmore Hall review - songs of love old and new
First-rate chamber choir explore contemporary and Renaissance approaches to amour
People, Places and Things, Trafalgar Theatre review - a scintillating shot in the arm
Duncan MacMillan’s riotous reflection on addiction and recovery returns
Album: Jack Savoretti - Miss Italia
Middle of the road singer embraces family history with an album of Italian pop
Jack Doherty, Soho Theatre review - warm and witty childhood memoir
Former chat show host on his David Bowie obsession
Withnail and I, Birmingham Rep review - Bruce Robinson’s 1987 film makes for a theatrical hit
Withnail and Marwood fix up the Jag and head for Birmingham
Two Tickets to Greece review - the highs and lows of a holiday from hell
Laure Calamy, Olivia Côte and Kristin Scott Thomas star in a silly French comedy
Add comment